Posted By David Rothkopf Share

If the health care legislation passed in Washington over the weekend is a watershed, it is not for the reason you may think. It's not because it is such a big piece of social legislation or because it represents such a big victory for President Obama. Both conclusions come with caveats -- either about what and who was not addressed by the legislation or about the political fallout from the ugly process that created this important but imperfect band-aid on America's broken health care system.

No, the reason the health care reform bill is important is not because it was the first major such piece of social legislation in the U.S. in decades, but rather because it represents the first in what will become by necessity an on-going series of efforts to fix deep and serious defects in the American economy. In a decade or two, this legislation is like to be seen by Americans as the beginning of a lengthy, brutal and spasmodic process to cut deficits and restore America's leadership prospects in the global economy. 

Health care is 20 percent of the U.S. economy and growing. It is linked to the part of the U.S. government's obligations that are expected to explode in the next decade and create mountains of debt that make those accumulated in the past few years look small by comparison. The inability to pay the bills that will come due, the inefficiency in the system, the drag the current system is placing on U.S. competitiveness -- all will demand that this is bill number one in a long series of efforts.

The Republican Party, which has discredited itself more with its stance on this bill than on any other of its signature initiatives since the McCarthy era (and I include the wrong-headed Iraq War on that list), will define whether it is relevant going forward by whether it moves from a brainless position of "oppose" and now "repeal" to one of seriously seeking meaningful solutions to this fire in the engine room of the U.S. economy. (Their mendacity and mean-spiritedness, their deviousness and hypocrisy throughout have been stunning. Do they really want to be known as a coalition of the stupid, the greedy and the uncaring? That's the message being offered by the Boehner-McConnell-Teabagger team.)

But let's look past the recent debate in Washington and toward what the global implications of this are. If America doesn't fix the health care problem as an aging, deficit burdened society, the country will watch its financial resources dwindle and those we have be siphoned into essential but costly social programs. This bill is a step in the direction of acknowledging the problem, addressing some grotesque social wrongs perpetrated by the current system and edging toward some slightly enhanced efficiency. Future legislation will have to make real headway at cutting deficits by increasingly cutting out the middlemen (insurance companies) we can't afford and by enhancing savings through greater efficiency. Changing the retirement age, limiting certain extremely expensive procedures and adding taxes will also be among the unpopular essentials of this process... and you can guess which party will take the lead with each.

The process is akin to reinvesting in infrastructure, changing our energy paradigm and revitalizing our educational system in terms of the basics of making America competitive again. Heck, these changes are essential to making America viable for the long-run. So while it is tempting to breathe a sigh of relief that with some luck the shouts of "baby killer" are behind us, Americans and those interested in what will be preoccupying the U.S. government for the next several decades ought to see this legislation not as the end, nor as the beginning of the end but perhaps, in the words of Churchill, as the end of the beginning -- although if the next stages of these reforms don't ultimately come, then Churchill will be paraphrased and the beginning of the end it will have been.

Pete Souza/White House via Getty Images

 

F1FAN

2:05 PM ET

March 23, 2010

The real history making moment

The Democrats actually standing up to the GOP for once. I've never seen a party with a majority and the President act so timid and gutless.

 

PFNOVAK

2:23 PM ET

March 23, 2010

Who did the Democrats stand

Who did the Democrats stand up to, exactly? They had a significant majority in both the House and Congress, they tweaked the bill until the Insurance Companies signed off on it (when they're the real problem), the AMA gave its blessing, and they sold out one of the core social issues of the party (abortion) to get it done. They could blame the GOP monster under the bed during the Bush years, with rapidly expanding executive power and a ruthlessly efficient majority in congress, but the democrats have had the house since '06 and the White House since last year. This bill was a timid, short-sighted, please many and help none affair. I didn't agree with Republican objections or tactics, which will ultimately hurt them, but I think the bill will not be a comprehensive long-term solution.

 

MARKLESNER

10:57 AM ET

April 17, 2010

Exactly all other leading

Exactly all other leading states worked out their balances between private and governmental participation in health care, to them it's a dead issue. Logo Design

 

VIJ

3:06 PM ET

April 17, 2010

menstrual problems

Whatever. US Health Care system is so much better than the place where I come from, India.

Menstrual Cramps

 

FLURGLE

6:38 PM ET

April 17, 2010

Healthcare

No offence but I am really glad that I do not live in the U.S.

With the problems I and my family have ( Diabetes, MS, Autism, ADD, etc) we would be bankrupt trying to pay for the meds and hospital treatment, whereas here in the U.K we get everything paid from the NHS. Ok we have to pay for it by taxes but as we pay taxes on everything we earn and buy the cost to us is nothing.

Sky Bingo

 

MORGANJAMES

7:53 PM ET

April 19, 2010

but who is going to pay for it all?

The problem that most people don't understand is that yes, you do pay much higher taxes in order to have the health care you do.

The problem is who is going to pay for it all, our country is in a state of economic bondage many of the people who want universal health care are also the the people who don't pay any taxes... the poor. You can't keep taxing the rich to pay for everybody else. I think if the poor had to contribute financially they would have a very different opinion about how great universal health care is.

While I think the idea of universal health care is a great idea I also think that the current plan is awful.

 

VIJ

5:23 AM ET

April 18, 2010

Health care

Health care is expensive in US isn't it. My sister is a dentist and has been practicing for about 2 years in Illinois. She is drawing 240k per annum. Isn't that a great pay for a dentist with 2 years experience. Surely they must be charging high to command that kind of remuneration.

Mary Statue and Lion Statue

 

LOLCAT

11:52 AM ET

April 18, 2010

healthcare

The NHS in UK may not be the best model around, but it is helpful for treatment and the nurses and doctors do a marvellous job
medicalsalesjobs

 

RUTHTYLOR

6:03 AM ET

April 19, 2010

healthcare

You wrote:
"The NHS in UK may not be the best model around, but it is helpful for treatment and the nurses and doctors do a marvellous job"
and I agree with that, they did a great work there,
Girl Games

 

READER MICHAEL

2:35 PM ET

April 19, 2010

Well, I really hope the

Well, I really hope the health care reform bill can benefit more people. Fpr common people health is just health, nothing else should be involved.

 

MARYOSURAC

4:16 PM ET

April 19, 2010

Health Bill Mandate

As far as I can tell, the health care bill is nothing more than a federal mandate requiring all citizens to have health coverage. I have a feeling it will be a terrible mistake and actually end up as a financial mess. The government has been swinging for the fence with health care, fha refinance
and modification programs, the bank bailout, and the jobs program. I don't think they hit a home run with the health care bill, more like a ground out to short.

 

FLORIDADUDE

1:56 PM ET

April 20, 2010

Who read it?

Well the health care bill passed, and I doubt 90% of the people that voted for it, read it. I'm not saying it's good or bad, but how do they know if it's going to "save" the country if nobody read it?
machu picchu tours

 

KWANH

7:00 PM ET

April 20, 2010

health or war

US should stop spending billions at war and use those resources in order to improve health care system.
Yemek Tarifleri

 

RONIBEN

7:19 PM ET

April 21, 2010

Agree

as you say "The NHS in UK may not be the best model around, but it is helpful for treatment and the nurses and doctors do a marvellous job
in my opinion and we both agree on that this guys did a great job there
Dora games

 

DALEANN8875

11:44 PM ET

April 21, 2010

The healthcare issue & how

The healthcare issue & how its being handled has shown the world just how "human" the US government is. Some people actually believed that compared to most 3rd world countries, the US has a government that is to envied due to lack of corruption (or at least how little it was). I guess this just shows that they're as bad as everyone else. They just know how to hide their greed better.
Dale Schnell Abnehmen

 

David Rothkopf is the CEO and Editor-at-Large of Foreign Policy. His new book, "Power, Inc.: The Epic Rivalry Between Big Business and Government and the Reckoning that Lies Ahead" is due out from Farrar, Straus & Giroux on March 1.

Read More