Thursday, June 18, 2009 - 11:01 PM

After all the flying I've been doing the past couple weeks, I was genuinely sorry to hear today's story of the Continental Airlines pilot who died while flying back from Belgium.
While resisting the tasteless temptation to observe that dying after having visited Belgium strikes me as needlessly repetitive, I have to say the story hit home because on my flight last night back from Latin America I was actually surprised that the "cabin service director" did not herself expire mid-flight. This woman was so old that at one point during the flight I thought I could actually hear her osteoporosis. While I admire her for setting such a good example for other senior citizens by continuing to work, I do feel that her insistence on wearing a leather flying helmet and a jaunty scarf she held on to from her days in the Lafayette Escadrille was a bit unnerving to the other passengers. It wasn't too unnerving however, because we hardly saw her. Being that this was a flight on a U.S. carrier from Latin America, she did not actually feel compelled to speak to a single passenger during the flight (I don't think I'm exaggerating here). She just sat up front and every so often would make an announcement that was so unintelligible that it made Jimmy Carter's mumblings the other day on behalf of Hamas seem coherent.
Speaking of that other octogenarian, you couldn't help but be struck by two things while watching Carter offer the weight of the office bestowed upon him by the American people to lend support to the Hezbollah-backed group of allegedly reforming terrorists. (You can imagine the 12 step program Hamas is running to keep its guys "political": "Hi, I am Khaled and I am a terrorist. I have not launched a missile at a nursery school in 17 weeks.")
The first was: "Aha! Here is an American president who is not afraid to stand up for an Iranian political movement."
The second was that for once I wish Walt and Mearsheimer were right, and that taking a stand that was anathema to the Israel Lobby really did mean the end of a political career in the United States, because Jimmy is well past his sell-by date. (For more on this last point, see Jeffrey Goldberg's observations on "The Taboo That Won't Shut Up.")
Carter's signature message was "Never before in history has a large community been savaged by bombs and missiles and then deprived of the means to repair itself." The view is so typically one-sided in its selective recollection of history -- he neglects to note who, for example, fired the first 10,000 or so missiles in the recent confrontation -- that it would make Carter the Flat Stanley of U.S. politics were it not for the fact that Flat Stanley actually had two dimensions. (And I say this as someone who believes that the international community and the Israelis owe it to the Palestinians to help them heal and to find a sustainable solution that offers both them and their neighbors dignity, security, and a chance at prosperity.)
Finally, as a parent, I found myself misting up a bit at Chastity Bono's recent reappearance in the news. (Since her father ended up being a Congressman, I think it's perfectly appropriate to discuss her in this blog. Chastity is a Washington insider once-removed. Although frankly as a lesbian child of celebrities, she probably makes it as a Washington insider entirely on her own what with this being a Democratic administration and all.) In any event, given the fame of her parents, you can't help but feel for poor Chaz, wondering how she was going to make a name for herself. Yet, here she has done it. With her decision to have a sex-change operation, she boldly went into the one area of plastic surgery her iconic mother never considered. (Which is saying something, as the only thing left about Cher that is authentic is the signature on her monthly retainer checks to the plastic surgeon she keeps on call.)
And the international affairs insight in the Chastity Bono story? (Besides the fact that post-surgery she will be the only other person still using the same first name as one-time National Intelligence Council nominee Chas Freeman.) Well, presumably if she could find someone who would sew a pair on her perhaps we might look into a way to do the same for our current foreign policy.
Irresistible sexist jokes aside, I am pretty sure our current problem is not so much the amount of testosterone in our system -- the feminist in me actually thinks you can never have too little -- as it is the vaguely masochistic impulse to effectively respond to every threat or provocation with an Oliver Twist-like, "Please, sir, may I have some more?"
MAHMUD HAMS/AFP/Getty Images
Is this really Foreign Policy?
I find it hard to believe that all the words offered by David Rothkopf today were to be taken seriously. Lesbians, sex chnges, octogenarians etc., and then trying to get serious with
"and I say this as someone who believes that the international community and the Israelis owe it to the Palestinians to help them heal and to find a sustainable solution that offers both them and their neighbors dignity, security, and a chance at prosperity.)". What next?
I guess one can be a comedy writer or a serious commentator but trying to be both in one article just doesn't make it for me.
You can lowball Carter if you wish but he is making an effort, as opposed to the total inactivity of past US Presidents, to their disgrace, blindly supporting the arrogant viewpoint of the Israelis, still in vogue, such efforts showing others that the US could have another face, an independent face, as unlikely as that must seem to any Palestinian. The Arab nations think he may be listening to their point of view, somewhat refreshing for them.
Just grabbing the Carter activities out of today's potpourri of irrelevant subjects one should remember that he seems to find a Middle East solution a lot more important than some of our commentators, so it seems.
He may be old, which Mr. Rothkopf finds worthy of ridicule as with the air hostess segment, but more strength to him.
The first was: "Aha! Here is an American president who is not afraid to stand up for an Iranian political movement."
You're half-joking, but I still feel obligated to point out that Hamas's contacts with Iran basically amount to sending a bunch of their grunts to Iran to train, and occasionally getting weapons and some funding from them. It's not as if they're a puppet for the Iranian government - they're a violent, largely Sunni Palestinian Islamist militia.
Your comments about Chaz Bono are shockingly disrespectful. I expected more from Foreign Policy. I mean really - not even using the correct pronouns? Framing his choice to transition as a publicity stunt? And this sentence:
Well, presumably if she could find someone who would sew a pair on her perhaps we might look into a way to do the same for our current foreign policy.
Well, where to start? Maybe the fact that you have, as is too common in our society, conflated bravery and boldness with maleness.
the feminist in me
Oh yes, the feminist who finds sexist jokes "irresitible." Some feminist. My advice - try harder to resist. These "jokes" dehumanize and marginalize women and trans people. This dehumanization has real effects for real people - they make it easier for people like Allen Ray Andrade to kill us and for society to excuse their actions as understandable. These are effects that you may not have to worry about. How lucky for you.
FP offers a wide range of far more reputable bloggers to those who don't like the mix of humor and seriousness here. Or the humor. Or the seriousness. There are also lots of bloggers on these issues from which to choose who are not at FP. I'm just doing the best I can.
Sometimes, the attempts at humor, when they are at the expense of someone like Carter, I think help make a serious point. Because actually Carter, who is almost never that funny, is a bit of a sad joke in my eyes. Not because he tries to help. Not because he is trying to help bring long-overdue to peace and better lives to the Palestinians. But because he is being used again, values his own industry (or time in the sun) more than he values the efforts of the U.S. government, is interfering with the work of yet another sitting president and earns the opprobrium he generates.
As for the last comment, regarding Chastity Bono...well, it gives me pause. My joke was reflexive and that's not a good thing. In retrospect, I regret it.
So...if you're keeping score...I stand by making a mockery of bad U.S. airline service, the rude woman on last night's flight in particular, of Jimmy Carter, of the tepid Obama reaction on Iran, of Hamas and I stand by attempting to mix humor and seriousness. And I apologize for contributing to an environment which cannot be an easy one for the trans-gender community.
David,
Aside from your penetrating insight into a wide array of topics, the thing I like best about your blog is that I usually get a good laugh or two.
With all the serious problems in the world today, such as global warming, nuclear weapons, Iraq, Iran, North Korea, the economy, home forclosures, unemployment, the stock market, swine flu, Pakistan, the Taliban, al Queda, and Osama bin Laden, a good laugh is a good thing - even if it is occasionally at one's own expense.
For everyone who is offended, get a life and take a xanax!
Mr.Rothkopf- what a disappointment. I say this as someone who has lurked on this blog since its inception and have followed your various editorials and appearances on CSPAN and what not. If I wanted TMZ or perezhilton, I believe I know where on the web to find such commentary.
Carter is a hero and this Rothkopf is a shonda on the Jews. Just what we Jews need - more chauvinism. Not.
Again-- just embarrassing commentary. I won't even bother responding to the Carter stuff. But Chastity Bono... Does anyone take Rothkopf seriously? Chastity Bono? WTF? Is this the Drudge Report?
David Rothkopf is the CEO and Editor-at-Large of Foreign Policy. His new book, "Power, Inc.: The Epic Rivalry Between Big Business and Government and the Reckoning that Lies Ahead" is due out from Farrar, Straus & Giroux on March 1.
Read More
(8)
HIDE COMMENTS LOGIN OR REGISTER REPORT ABUSE